Genres

Plotting a mystery: fair clues and the reveal

A good mystery plays fair. The reader has every clue they need, and is still surprised. How to build the solution first, hide clues in plain sight, handle red herrings and land a reveal that feels both shocking and inevitable.

By The IdeaToBook team7 min read

A mystery makes a deal with its reader. It says: here is a puzzle, and everything you need to solve it is in these pages. If you’re clever enough, you can get there before the detective. When the solution comes, the reader should feel two things at once: surprise that they didn’t see it, and satisfaction that they could have.

That double feeling is what mystery writers are aiming for, and it’s hard. Make the clues too obvious and the reader solves it by chapter five. Hide them too well, or leave them out, and the ending feels like a cheat. This post is about getting that balance right.

The idea of fair play

The idea that a mystery should play fair with its reader was argued over and codified during what’s often called the Golden Age of detective fiction, between the two world wars. In 1928 the American writer S. S. Van Dine published a list of twenty rules for detective stories, and in 1929 the British writer and priest Ronald Knox set out his “Ten Commandments” of detection. The Detection Club, a London dining club of crime writers formed around 1930 whose early members included Agatha Christie and Dorothy L. Sayers, had its members swear an oath that, in part, promised fair dealing with the reader.

Some of those rules are dated and some were written half in jest. But the central principle has lasted: the detective shouldn’t solve the crime with information the reader never saw. Every clue the detective uses must have been shown to the reader at some point, however well disguised.

Modern crime fiction is more varied than the classic puzzle. Thrillers, police procedurals and psychological suspense don’t always ask the reader to solve anything. But even in those, readers feel cheated if the ending depends on something that came from nowhere.

Build the solution first

Most mystery writers agree on one thing: you need to know the solution before you can write the clues. Some discover their solution while drafting and then rewrite heavily, which works too. But the solution has to exist, in detail, before the final draft.

Start with what really happened. Write it out as a plain account, in order, from the culprit’s point of view:

  • who did it, and why
  • how they did it, step by step
  • what they did afterwards to cover it up
  • what went wrong for them (the mistake that will eventually give them away)
  • who else knows something, and why they’re not telling

This is the hidden story. Your novel is the story of the investigation, which uncovers the hidden story out of order and through other people’s eyes. Every clue in the book is a place where the hidden story leaks into the visible one.

What makes a fair clue

A clue is any piece of information that points towards the truth. Fair clues share some features.

They’re on the page. The reader sees the clue directly, or hears it, in a scene. It isn’t summarised in a sentence the detective says later.

They’re there before the reveal. Ideally well before. A clue that turns up a page before the solution, just in time to be used, doesn’t feel fair.

They’re ambiguous at first. A good clue can be read two ways. When it appears, it seems to mean one thing, or nothing at all. After the reveal, it clearly means something else.

They’re in proportion. The solution shouldn’t rest on a single obscure detail. Several clues, each small, pointing the same way when you look back, are more satisfying than one big one.

Hiding clues in plain sight

The craft of mystery writing is largely the craft of misdirection: showing the reader a clue in a way that makes them not notice it, or notice the wrong thing about it. Some reliable techniques:

Put the clue in a list. A clue mentioned alongside several irrelevant details is much less noticeable than one mentioned alone. The detective searches a room and finds a train ticket, a hairbrush, an unopened letter and a pair of muddy boots. Which one matters?

Hide it in action. A clue mentioned during an exciting or emotional scene slips past readers whose attention is elsewhere. A detail dropped during an argument is hard to spot.

Give it a false explanation. Show the clue, then immediately offer an innocent reason for it. The reader accepts the reason and moves on. Later, the innocent reason turns out to be untrue.

Let a character the reader trusts dismiss it. If the sympathetic sidekick says “that’s nothing”, readers tend to agree.

Place it early. Clues in the first few chapters, before the reader knows what kind of puzzle it is, are easy to forget.

Use the reader’s assumptions. Readers make assumptions about time, identity, gender, relationships and who is likely to be guilty. A story can show information accurately while letting readers draw the wrong conclusion. The key word is accurately: the text mustn’t lie, even if characters do.

Red herrings

A red herring is a false clue: something that points convincingly towards the wrong answer. Mysteries need them, because without them the reader has only one place to look.

Good red herrings follow some rules of their own:

  • They should have an explanation, which the book eventually gives. A suspicious detail that’s simply forgotten feels like a loose end.
  • They should be as interesting as the real clues. If the false trail is obviously weaker, readers will ignore it.
  • They often work best when they point to a real secret, just not the murder. The suspect was lying about where they were that night, but because they were having an affair, not because they killed anyone. This gives the red herring its own payoff.

The classic structure gives you several suspects, each with a motive, an opportunity and a secret. The investigation uncovers the secrets one by one, eliminating suspects as it goes, until only the truth is left.

The detective’s reasoning

Whether your detective is a police officer, a private investigator or an amateur, readers need to follow their thinking, at least partly. A detective who simply knows the answer, with no visible reasoning, is frustrating.

The usual approach is to let the reader see what the detective sees, but not always what they think about it. The detective notices the muddy boots; the reader sees them noticing; but the detective doesn’t explain why they matter until the end. This keeps the reader in the game without giving the answer away.

If you use a first-person narrator who isn’t the detective (the friend-and-chronicler tradition), that narrator can see everything the detective does while understanding less, which is a convenient way of being fair to the reader while keeping the secret.

The reveal

The reveal is the payoff, and it has to do several jobs at once.

It must be surprising. If most readers guess it early, the clues were too strong or the red herrings too weak.

It must be inevitable. Looking back, the reader should see that it could only have been this person, for these reasons. If several solutions would fit the clues equally well, the reveal feels arbitrary.

It must explain everything. Every clue, and every red herring, needs an explanation. Make a list of all the clues and false trails in your draft and check them off.

It must happen through action, not only explanation. The traditional scene where the detective gathers everyone and explains the solution can be satisfying, but it works better when there’s still something at stake: a confession to be won, a culprit who might escape, a danger still in the room. Pure explanation can turn the climax into a lecture.

A useful test: tell the solution to a friend who has read the book. If they say “of course!” rather than “but how?”, the clues were fair.

Revising a mystery

Mysteries are revised more heavily than most fiction, because the clues have to be adjusted once you can see the whole book. A practical method:

  1. Make a clue map. List every clue and red herring with the chapter where it appears and the chapter where it’s explained.
  2. Check the gaps. Is any clue introduced too late? Does any red herring go unexplained? Are the clues bunched in one part of the book?
  3. Check the timeline. Write the hidden story’s timeline beside the investigation’s. Contradictions hide in dates, days of the week and travel times.
  4. Give it to readers. Ask test readers to write down who they suspect, and when, at the end of each chapter. You’ll see exactly where the solution became obvious, or where readers lost the thread.

If you plan your mysteries before writing, the outline is especially important: you’ll want the solution and the clue map before the first chapter. Our post on outlining without killing the magic covers how to plan a book loosely enough to enjoy writing it, which matters in a genre where so much has to be decided in advance.

IdeaToBook has a mystery and thriller book type, and its interview is a useful place to set down your hidden story before the outline is drafted (the guide to writing a novel shows the steps). The clue map, though, is a job for a pencil and the whole manuscript spread out in front of you. Fairness to the reader is something you check by hand.

Help & feedback

Talk to the people who make IdeaToBook. A person reads every message.

Have an account? See your messages. Or email support@ideatobook.my.