Craft

How to find your book idea (and test it in an afternoon)

Most people don’t lack a book idea. They have several half-ideas and no way to tell which one will last 40,000 words. Here’s how to find the strong one, and a four-hour test before you commit.

By The IdeaToBook team8 min read

People who say they’d like to write a book rarely have no idea at all. More often they have three or four: a guide to the thing they do at work, a novel that has been circling for years, a family story, a collection of recipes their friends keep asking for. The difficulty isn’t finding an idea. It’s knowing which one will still be alive at chapter nine, when the early excitement has gone and the writing has become a job.

This post is about that choice. First, where the strong ideas tend to come from. Then a simple test you can run in one afternoon, with a notebook and no special tools, before you spend months on something that was never going to hold.

Start with what you already know

The best first books, fiction or non-fiction, tend to come from knowledge the author already has and takes for granted. A nurse knows what a night shift actually feels like. A carpenter knows which mistakes beginners make with a chisel and why. A grandmother knows the bread recipe nobody wrote down. Because this knowledge feels ordinary to you, it’s easy to overlook. It isn’t ordinary to readers.

Try this: write down every subject on which a friend has asked you for advice more than once. Not subjects you’d like to be an expert on. Subjects people already come to you about. Then write down the jobs you’ve held, the places you’ve lived, the hobbies you’ve kept for more than five years and the hard things you’ve been through. That list is your raw material.

For fiction the same rule applies, just at a slant. Crime novelists are often drawn from professions that see the underside of life; historical novelists often begin with a place or a period they’ve read about for years. Your novel doesn’t have to be about your job, but it will be richer if its world is one you know from the inside.

Look for an itch, not a topic

“Gardening” is a topic. “How to grow most of your vegetables in a small urban garden without a greenhouse” is an itch: a specific problem, felt by specific people, with an answer you can give. Topics produce encyclopaedias. Itches produce books people finish.

The same is true of stories. “A novel about grief” is a topic. “A woman clearing out her late father’s flat finds a key to a storage unit she didn’t know he rented” is an itch. It raises a question the reader wants answered.

When you look at your list, ask of each idea: whose problem does this solve, or what question does this raise? If you can’t name the reader or the question, the idea is still a topic. Keep narrowing until you can.

Three questions to sort the list

Once you have five or six candidate ideas, put each one through these questions. Be honest; nobody else is reading.

Can I say it in one sentence? Not a slogan, just a plain sentence: “A practical guide for new managers on running their first one-to-one meetings.” “A mystery set in a ferry port, in which the harbour master is the only person who can’t have done it.” If the sentence keeps sprawling, the idea isn’t clear yet. That doesn’t mean it’s bad. It means it needs more thought before it needs writing.

Do I know more than the reader, or care more than anyone else? Non-fiction needs one of these and ideally both. You don’t have to be the world authority. You have to be far enough ahead of your reader to lead them, and honest about where your knowledge stops. Fiction needs the second: some obsession with the people, the place or the question that will carry you through the slow middle.

Will I still want to think about this in six months? A book takes a long time, even with help. If an idea is fashionable rather than personal, it tends to go stale on you. The ideas that last are usually the ones you’d think about anyway, book or no book.

The afternoon test

Here is the part that saves the most time. Before you commit to an idea, give it one afternoon: about four hours, split into four tasks. If the idea survives all four, it’s worth writing. If it collapses at one of them, you’ve learned where the weak point is, cheaply.

Hour one: the reader and the promise

Write a paragraph describing one specific reader. Give them a situation, not a demographic. “Someone who has just been promoted to lead the team they used to be part of, and is dreading the first difficult conversation” is a reader. “Professionals aged 25–45” is not.

Then write the promise: what will this reader have, know or feel by the last page that they don’t now? For a how-to book, it’s usually a capability (“you’ll be able to run a fair, short, useful one-to-one every week”). For a novel, it’s an experience (“you’ll spend a winter in a ferry port, suspect everyone and be surprised by the ending”).

If you can’t write the reader or the promise, stop here. Go back to narrowing.

Hour two: the chapter list

Without worrying about order or wording, write down every chapter you can imagine. Aim for at least twelve. For non-fiction, each chapter should be a step, a question or a problem the reader has. For fiction, write the major events you already know about, even if they’re vague: “she finds the key”, “the first visit to the storage unit”, “the brother turns up”.

Count them. If you run dry at five or six, the idea may be an article or a long blog post rather than a book. That’s a useful result, not a failure. Some ideas are better short. If you can fill a page and keep going, that’s a strong sign.

Hour three: write the hardest page

Most people test an idea by writing the opening, because openings are fun. Write the hardest page instead. In a how-to book, that’s usually the chapter where the method gets difficult: the bit where beginners give up. In a novel, it’s often a scene in the middle where two characters want different things and neither is obviously right.

You’re not trying to write it well. You’re checking whether you have something to say when the easy material runs out. If you find yourself with plenty of material, even messy material, the idea has depth. If you stare at the page and realise you don’t know what happens, or don’t know how the method actually works at this point, you’ve found a gap you’ll need to fill with research or thinking before you start.

Hour four: the shelf check

Spend the last hour looking at what already exists. Search an online bookshop for the books your reader would find if they went looking today. Read the descriptions and, where you can, the sample pages. Read a few of the three-star reviews: they’re often the most useful, because they say what readers wanted and didn’t get.

You’re looking for two things. First, proof that readers want this kind of book at all. If nobody has ever written anything close to it, that’s more often a warning than an opportunity. Second, a gap: an angle, a reader or a level of practicality the existing books miss. “The other books on one-to-ones are written for HR departments; mine is for the person in the chair” is a gap. So is “every cosy mystery set by the sea seems to be in Cornwall; mine is in a working ferry port”.

If the shelf is crowded and you can’t see your gap, keep the idea but change the angle. If it’s crowded and you can see your gap clearly, good: you’ve found a market that exists and a reason for your book to exist in it.

What a passing idea looks like

At the end of the afternoon, a strong idea gives you:

  • one sentence that says what the book is
  • one reader you can picture, and a promise to them
  • a dozen or more chapters, roughly sketched
  • one hard page that shows you have something to say
  • a clear sense of how your book differs from what’s already on the shelf

That’s most of a book proposal, and it’s most of what you need to start an outline. (Our post on outlining without killing the magic picks up from here.)

When two ideas both pass

It happens. Usually the answer is to write the one that’s more specific first. Specific books are easier to finish, easier to describe to readers and easier to sell. The broader idea often becomes your second book, and it’ll be better for what you learned on the first.

If you still can’t choose, ask which one you’d be more embarrassed not to have written in five years’ time. That one.

A note on “it’s been done”

Almost everything has been done. There are thousands of books on bread, hundreds of novels about a detective in a small town, and more books on leadership than anyone could read. This is not a reason to stop. Readers don’t want a book that has never been written before; they want the book that fits their situation, in a voice they trust.

What hasn’t been done is your version: your recipes, tested in your kitchen; your examples, from your working life; your ferry port. The afternoon test is partly a way of finding out what that version is. If you can say clearly how your book is yours, “it’s been done” stops mattering.

Where IdeaToBook fits

This whole process works with a notebook, and you don’t need any software to do it. If you’d like help with the next step, IdeaToBook starts in the same place this post does: a one-sentence idea, then a short interview about what you know, then an outline with a promise for each chapter that you edit and approve before any writing starts. The interview and outline are free, so it can be a quick way to see your afternoon’s work laid out as a book. You can read more about how the AI book writer works.

Either way, give your idea the afternoon. It’s the cheapest four hours you’ll spend on your book.

Help & feedback

Talk to the people who make IdeaToBook. A person reads every message.

Have an account? See your messages. Or email support@ideatobook.my.