Show, don’t tell, and when to tell
The most repeated piece of writing advice is also one of the most misunderstood. What “show, don’t tell” really means, why it works, and the many moments when telling is exactly the right choice.
If you’ve been to a writing class, you’ve heard it: show, don’t tell. It’s written in the margins of manuscripts, repeated in craft books and quoted in online forums, often without much explanation. Followed blindly, it produces bloated scenes where nothing can be said plainly. Ignored, it produces flat summaries where nothing is felt.
Like most good rules, it makes sense once you understand what it’s for. And like most good rules, it has exceptions that matter just as much as the rule.
What the rule actually means
“Telling” gives the reader a conclusion. “Showing” gives them the evidence and lets them reach the conclusion themselves.
Telling: Tom was nervous about the interview.
Showing: Tom checked the time on his phone, put it away, and checked it again. He’d read the job description four times on the train. In the lift he realised he’d been holding his breath.
The first version is efficient and clear. The second takes longer, but the reader experiences Tom’s nerves instead of being informed about them. They do a little work, and that work makes the moment feel real. Readers trust what they’ve worked out for themselves more than what they’ve been told.
That’s the principle: when a moment matters emotionally, let the reader see it happen.
Why showing works
There are a few reasons showing tends to be more powerful.
It’s specific. “Nervous” is a category. Checking the phone twice is a detail. Specific details are what make writing vivid and believable, because they’re the kind of thing that would only be in this story.
It involves the reader. When readers infer an emotion from behaviour, they’re participating. It’s the difference between being told a joke is funny and laughing at it.
It allows ambiguity. If you write “Sarah was angry”, that’s settled. If you write “Sarah put the cup down very carefully”, the reader might read anger, or grief, or a decision being made. Sometimes you want that openness.
It’s how we experience life. We don’t receive labels for other people’s feelings. We read faces, tones of voice and actions. Fiction that works the same way feels closer to experience.
The common mistakes
Writers who take the rule too literally tend to make one of three mistakes.
Showing everything
If every small moment is dramatised, the book slows to a crawl. A character doesn’t need a full scene to travel from home to work unless something happens on the way. Readers can feel when they’re being made to watch something unimportant in slow motion.
Showing, then telling anyway
This is very common in early drafts:
Tom checked the time on his phone, put it away, and checked it again. He was really nervous.
The second sentence explains what the first already showed. It’s the writer not trusting the reader, and the reader can tell. In revision, look for sentences that name an emotion straight after you’ve shown it, and cut them.
Showing with clichés
Some “showing” is so familiar that it works like telling. Hearts pound, fists clench, breath catches, eyes widen. These aren’t wrong, but they’re shortcuts, and readers glide over them. The best showing finds the specific gesture: the phone checked twice, the job description read four times. Ask what this person would do.
When telling is the right choice
Here is the half of the advice that’s often left out. Good writers tell all the time. They just choose when.
Transitions and time. “Three weeks passed before she heard back” is telling, and it’s exactly right. Dramatising three weeks of waiting would be tedious. Summary lets you move through time quickly so you can slow down for the scenes that matter.
Background the reader needs quickly. If the reader needs to know that two characters were married for ten years before the story begins, often the best thing is to say so. You can show the texture of that marriage later, when it matters.
Small emotions. Not every feeling deserves a scene. “He was mildly irritated by the delay” is fine if the irritation doesn’t matter much. Save your showing for the emotions that drive the story.
Voice. Some narrators tell beautifully. A confident first-person narrator, or an omniscient narrator with a strong personality, can summarise and comment in ways that are a pleasure to read. The telling becomes part of the character.
Clarity. If a reader might misread a moment and that would genuinely confuse them, a sentence of telling can save a lot of trouble. Ambiguity is a tool, not a virtue in itself.
A useful way to think about it: showing is slow and intense, telling is fast and efficient. A good book uses both, choosing the speed that suits each moment, like a film that cuts between close-ups and wide shots.
Show and tell in non-fiction
The rule is usually taught for fiction, but it applies to non-fiction too, in a slightly different form.
In a how-to book, “telling” is stating a principle: Proving dough in a warm place speeds it up. “Showing” is a concrete example: In my kitchen in January, a loaf that takes two hours on the counter is ready in an hour next to the radiator.
Principles alone are hard to remember and easy to doubt. Examples alone don’t generalise. The strongest non-fiction does both: a principle, then an example, or an example, then the principle it illustrates. Case studies, stories from your own experience and worked examples are all forms of showing.
In memoir, the balance is close to fiction’s. Scenes carry the emotional weight; summary connects them and provides reflection. A memoir that’s all summary feels like a CV. One that’s all scenes can lack the perspective that makes a life story more than a series of events.
How to revise for it
Showing and telling are much easier to balance in revision than in drafting. When you write the first draft, don’t worry too much: tell where you need to, to keep moving. Then, on a revision pass:
- Find the key moments. Mark the five or six emotional turning points in each chapter, or the key ideas in a non-fiction chapter. These are candidates for showing.
- Check each one. Is it told in a single sentence? If so, can you replace that sentence with something the reader sees, hears or does?
- Find the slow patches. Look for scenes where nothing changes. Could they be summarised in a sentence or two?
- Cut the explanations. Look for sentences that name an emotion just after you’ve shown it. Delete them and see if the passage still works. It usually works better.
- Read aloud. Rhythm tells you a lot. A long stretch of showing with no breathing space feels breathless; a long stretch of telling feels like a lecture.
If you want a fuller method for revising a whole manuscript, our post on editing your own manuscript sets out three separate passes, and this is part of the second.
A quick exercise
Pick a sentence from your draft that names a feeling: She was furious, He felt lost, They were relieved. Rewrite it three ways, each time using only what an observer could see or hear: an action, a line of dialogue, or a detail in the setting. Then choose the version that’s most specific to that character.
Finally, ask whether the moment matters enough to need showing at all. If it doesn’t, put the original sentence back. Knowing when to tell is just as much a skill as knowing how to show.